You paid for this coverage so you would never have to argue about it, and now your own insurance company is the one asking questions. Rosenthal, Levy, Simon & Sosa Injury Lawyers represents people across Palm Beach County who are pursuing uninsured and underinsured motorist claims against their own carriers.
Our West Palm Beach uninsured motorist lawyers take over the claim, deal with the adjuster, and push it toward a fair payment or a courtroom. Call +1 (866) 640-7117 any hour, in English or Spanish, for a free review of your policy and your crash.
Table of contents
- Who Pays After a Crash With an Uninsured or Underinsured Driver?
- How a West Palm Beach UM Claim Against Your Own Insurer Unfolds
- Underinsured Driver? Florida's 30-Day Consent-to-Settle Rule
- What Must Your Injury Show Before UM Pays for Pain and Suffering?
- What Can You Do When Your Insurer Stalls or Lowballs?
- Court or Arbitration for a Disputed Uninsured Motorist Claim
- How Long Do You Have to File a UM Claim in Florida?
- Why Palm Beach County Drivers Choose Our Uninsured Motorist Lawyers
- Uninsured Motorist Lawyer Questions, Answered for West Palm Beach Drivers
- Your Policy, Read by Someone on Your Side
Who Pays After a Crash With an Uninsured or Underinsured Driver?
Your own policy steps in when the at-fault driver has little or no bodily injury coverage, within the coverage you bought, the people it insures, and your limits. If you are hit by an uninsured driver, personal injury protection (PIP) pays first, then the other driver's liability coverage, then uninsured motorist (UM) coverage up to your limit.
Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage is the same protection applied when the other driver has some insurance but not enough. Because Florida does not require most drivers to carry bodily injury liability, many claims our car accident attorneys handle end up on the injured person's own policy under section 627.727.
| Situation | Pays first | Pays next | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Driver has no BI coverage | Your PIP | Your UM | Proof of the other driver's fault |
| Driver has low BI limits | Your PIP | Their BI, then your UM | Your carrier's consent before settling |
| Driver is never identified | Your PIP | Your UM, per policy terms | Police report and contact rules |
| Driver's policy had lapsed | Your PIP | Your UM | Proof of the cancellation date |
BI means bodily injury liability, the coverage that pays people an at-fault driver hurts. The last column matters most, because each situation gives your carrier a different reason to slow down when determining who was at-fault for a car accident.
Attorney Steve Simon of our firm said it directly in an interview on WRPB: "In this state, you absolutely need to have it because this state does not have mandatory bodily injury coverage."
Does the Other Driver's Payment Reduce Your UM Limit?
No. Florida law says the UM coverage available is not reduced by a setoff against other coverage, including the at-fault driver's liability insurance.
If your damages total $150,000, the other driver carries $10,000, and you carry $100,000 in UM, the full $100,000 is still available after the $10,000 is paid. UM does not duplicate what PIP or medical payments coverage already paid, so those amounts come off the damages figure first.
A Short Word on Stacking
Stacked UM multiplies your limit by the number of vehicles on the policy, while non-stacking coverage limits you to one vehicle's amount. We confirm which version you bought before any number is discussed. Our guide to how UM coverage works covers the basics.
How a West Palm Beach UM Claim Against Your Own Insurer Unfolds
A UM claim follows a predictable path, and your carrier has rights at each stage that a stranger's insurer would not. The policy lets the company demand information, sworn testimony, and medical exams before it pays.
Most of our West Palm Beach UM files move in this order:
- Written notice of the claim to your carrier, as soon as the other driver's coverage is known
- A coverage check of the declarations page, the policy, and any signed UM selection form
- Medical records, bills, and wage proof gathered and sent together as one package
- A written demand that sets out fault, injuries, and the threshold facts
- Negotiation, and if needed, a lawsuit against the insurer in Palm Beach County
Disputes that reach a courtroom tend to turn on what was or was not sent at steps three and four, so we keep the full paper trail.
Your Duty to Cooperate
Your UM policy requires you to cooperate with the company's investigation, and a refusal hands the carrier a reason to deny or delay. Cooperation means answering reasonable requests and signing proper authorizations. It does not mean surrendering 20 years of unrelated medical records without a fight over scope.
Recorded Statements, Sworn Examinations, and Medical Exams
Expect three requests on a serious claim. The first is a recorded statement by phone, and the second can be an examination under oath, a formal session with a court reporter where the company's lawyer asks the questions.
The third is a compulsory medical exam with a doctor the insurer picks and pays. We prepare you for each one, attend the sworn examination with you, and object when a request goes beyond what the policy allows.
Underinsured Driver? Florida's 30-Day Consent-to-Settle Rule
When the at-fault driver has some coverage, Florida gives your UIM carrier 30 days to approve or block a settlement with that driver's insurer. Under section 627.727(6), you send written notice of the proposed settlement by certified or registered mail.
Your carrier then agrees, or pays you the amount of the offer itself so it can pursue the at-fault driver later. That second option is called preserving subrogation, meaning your insurer keeps the right to sue the other driver for what it paid.
The mistakes we see most in this stage are avoidable:
- Cashing the liability check before the 30-day notice period runs
- Signing a general release that also lets your own carrier off the hook
- Sending notice by regular mail or email instead of certified mail
- Forgetting a second UM policy in the household that also needs notice
Any one of these can cost money that was otherwise available. We send the notice letters ourselves and calendar the 30 days from the date each carrier signs for them.
What Must Your Injury Show Before UM Pays for Pain and Suffering?
UM coverage pays for pain, suffering, mental anguish, and inconvenience only when the injury meets Florida's tort threshold. Section 627.727(7) ties those damages to the standard in section 627.737, while medical bills and lost income beyond PIP are not subject to it.
The threshold is met by significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, a permanent injury within a reasonable degree of medical probability, or significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement. In practice, the fight is almost always about permanence.
Where PIP Fits Before UM
PIP pays 80% of reasonable medical bills and 60% of lost income up to $10,000, regardless of fault. Care must start within 14 days, and medical benefits stop at $2,500 without an emergency medical condition finding. Our overview of Palm Beach County no-fault rules explains that first layer.
Building the Permanency Record
Your insurer can request a medical exam or dispute how serious and permanent the injury is. We answer with the treating physician's records, imaging, and a written permanency opinion from a provider who has examined you over time.
What Can You Do When Your Insurer Stalls or Lowballs?
Florida gives policyholders a civil remedy against insurers that fail to settle in good faith when they could and should have done so. Under section 624.155, the process starts with a Civil Remedy Notice (CRN).
The CRN goes to the Florida Department of Financial Services (DFS) and the insurer at least 60 days before any bad faith lawsuit. It must name the statute violated, the facts behind the violation, and the policy language involved.
DFS accepts these through its online civil remedy system but takes no part in the negotiation. If the insurer pays the damages or corrects the problem within the 60 days, no bad faith action can follow.
Separately, DFS's Division of Consumer Services takes complaints about stalled claims and assigns each one to a member of its staff. That request can prompt a response from the carrier, but the agency does not decide what your claim is worth.
Why a Well-Drafted CRN Matters
A vague notice gives the company nothing to cure and gives a court a reason to reject the bad faith claim later.
The statute also says mere negligence by an insurer is not bad faith, so the notice has to point to more than a slow adjuster. We draft each CRN around the exact misconduct on the file, such as a refusal to evaluate submitted records.
What Happens if the Insurer Does Not Cure?
An expired cure period alone neither proves bad faith nor requires payment above the limits. You still must meet the statute's prerequisites and prove bad faith, usually after winning the UM claim. Understanding uninsured motorist laws in Florida is important because, if you meet those requirements, Florida law allows recovery of the full damages, including the amount above the policy limit.
Our firm has tried this sequence in Palm Beach County. A UM carrier refused to pay its $100,000 limit to a client rear-ended on I-95 by a driver with no liability insurance, and after a three-day trial the jury returned a verdict of over $400,000.
The firm then recovered the full verdict plus attorney's fees and expenses through a bad faith claim. Past results do not predict a similar outcome in another case.
Court or Arbitration for a Disputed Uninsured Motorist Claim
An unresolved UM claim in Palm Beach County ends up as a lawsuit against the insurer in the Fifteenth Judicial Circuit, unless the policy sends it elsewhere. Some policies include an arbitration clause, and its wording decides whether it is optional. We read that clause early.
Factors We Weigh Before Filing Suit
Several facts shape the choice between suing and accepting a negotiated number:
- The gap between the offer and documented medical expenses
- Whether a treating doctor supports permanency
- Whether a CRN has been filed and its 60 days have run
- How much of the policy limit the offer leaves unused
A West Palm Beach personal injury lawyer can explain each factor in plain terms, but the decision to file is yours. No attorney can promise what a jury or arbitrator will award.
How Long Do You Have to File a UM Claim in Florida?
Florida courts treat a UM claim as a contract claim, so the five-year deadline for written contracts in section 95.11(2)(b) applies, generally measured from the crash. Claims against the at-fault driver carry a two-year negligence deadline for crashes after March 24, 2023.
Your policy adds its own notice requirements, and late notice gives the carrier a defense. Policy terms and court rulings can shift when the UM clock starts, so we treat the two-year date as the working deadline.
Why Palm Beach County Drivers Choose Our Uninsured Motorist Lawyers
A UM claim is a fight with a company that holds your entire claims file, and we have been taking on insurers in this county since 1985. We know how carriers evaluate these files and what moves them.
What working with us looks like:
- A lawyer reads your full policy and any signed UM rejection or selection form
- We handle every call, letter, and recorded statement request from your carrier
- Consent-to-settle notices go out by certified mail on a tracked 30-day calendar
- Civil Remedy Notices are drafted to support a bad faith claim if one becomes necessary
- We look for every other policy in your household that could add UM coverage
- Attorneys and staff work in English and Spanish, and someone answers 24/7
Clients have given our firm a 4.9-star Google rating, and you can meet with us at our office at 1401 Forum Way in West Palm Beach. The first consultation is free.
If your carrier has delayed, denied, or made an offer that doesn't match your bills, call +1 (866) 640-7117 and let us review the claim.
Uninsured Motorist Lawyer Questions, Answered for West Palm Beach Drivers
People ask us these before hiring a lawyer for a UM or UIM claim in Palm Beach County.
How much does an uninsured motorist lawyer cost in West Palm Beach?
At Rosenthal, Levy, Simon & Sosa Injury Lawyers, most UM claims are handled on a contingency fee, with no upfront attorney's fees and a fee only if we recover money for you. The consultation is free, and a written agreement spells out the percentage before you sign.
What if my insurance company says I rejected UM coverage?
Ask for a copy of the signed form. Florida requires a UM rejection or lower-limit selection on a form approved by the Office of Insurance Regulation, and a signed form counts as an informed rejection. We check who signed, since a valid rejection by the named insured binds other insureds.
What if the other driver's insurance company refuses to cover the crash?
Florida law treats the at-fault car as uninsured in some of these situations, which opens your UM coverage. Examples include an insolvent insurer and a policy that excludes a nonfamily member who was driving. Other denials call for a review of both policies before you accept that no coverage exists.
Can I use my UM coverage if I was hit while driving for work?
Often, yes. If you file a workers' compensation claim, workers' compensation pays medical care and part of your wages regardless of fault, and a UM claim can pay damages workers' compensation does not, such as pain and suffering. Florida's UM statute bars duplicate payment for the same loss, so the two claims have to be coordinated.
Will my UM carrier pay my medical bills while the claim is pending?
Not as they come in. A UM claim is paid when it settles or ends in a verdict, while PIP and health insurance pay bills along the way. Health insurers can claim repayment from the UM recovery through a lien, so we resolve those amounts before money is distributed.
Your Policy, Read by Someone on Your Side
Your carrier already has an adjuster, a claims manual, and a lawyer on call. You should have someone reading the same policy for you before you answer another question from them.
Our West Palm Beach team at Rosenthal, Levy, Simon & Sosa Injury Lawyers will review your UM or UIM claim at no cost.
Bring your declarations page and call +1 (866) 640-7117. The line is staffed day and night, in English and Spanish.